Beyond the CV: Engaging with the Personal Stories of Candidates

1 month ago •

Beyond the CV: Engaging with the Personal Stories of Candidates

Recruitment is an incredibly competitive space, which has encouraged HR leaders and recruiters to find innovative ways to identify the best talent for roles. While a CV provides a snapshot of a candidate's professional and educational background, it often fails to capture the full essence of an individual's personality, character, and potential in a given job. So, in this article, we will discuss the importance of engaging with the personal stories of candidates, offering practical strategies for recruiters and HR professionals to gain deeper insights beyond the traditional CV.

The Limitations of Traditional CVs

Although a CV is a great way to gauge the overall skills and acumens of candidates, it doesn’t tell the whole story. A CV typically outlines a candidate's work experience, educational background, and skills. Many other attributes critical to job performance, such as resilience, creativity, and teamwork, are difficult to quantify on paper. Furthermore, a CV does not reveal how a candidate's unique experiences and perspectives might contribute to a diverse and innovative workplace environment. To create an authentic relationship with candidates, you should really be listening to their personal stories.

The Value of Personal Stories in Recruitment

Personal stories can reveal a wealth of information about a candidate's motivations, problem-solving skills, and adaptability - qualities that are often good to have in dynamic work environments. By engaging with these narratives, recruiters can make more informed decisions about how well an individual aligns with the company's culture and values.

  • Understanding Motivations and Values

Personal stories allow candidates to discuss the reasons behind their career choices and transitions. This insight can help recruiters assess whether a candidate's personal and professional values align with those of the organisation. For example, a candidate who speaks passionately about volunteering or community work may thrive in a company that values social responsibility.

  • Assessing Problem-Solving and Adaptability

When candidates share how they have overcome challenges or adapted to changes, recruiters gain insights into their problem-solving abilities. These stories can be particularly revealing, showing how candidates handle stress, manage complex projects, or innovate under pressure.

  • Highlighting Unique Contributions

Each candidate brings a unique set of experiences that can enrich a team's dynamic. Personal stories help illuminate these unique contributions, whether it's international work experience, diverse educational backgrounds, or unusual hobbies that have honed transferable skills. This can be incredibly helpful if your recruitment focus is leaning towards building diverse teams.

Strategies for Engaging with Personal Stories

Engaging with the personal stories of candidates requires thoughtful strategies that elicit meaningful insights while respecting the candidate’s privacy and relevance to the job role. Below are a few detailed strategies that recruiters and HR professionals can use to integrate personal narratives into the recruitment process effectively.

  • In-Depth Interviews

In-depth, semi-structured, interviews are an ideal format for exploring personal stories. These interviews should be designed with open-ended questions that prompt candidates to share experiences and insights that reveal their problem-solving abilities, resilience, and adaptability. For instance, questions like, “Can you describe a project where you had to learn a new skill under pressure?” or, “Tell us about a time when you turned a negative situation into a positive one at work” can provide deep insights into a candidate’s approach and character.

  • Behavioural Assessments

Behavioural assessments that include situational judgement tests can be used to understand how a candidate might react in specific scenarios related to the job. These assessments can be designed to reflect real challenges they might face in the role, offering a glimpse into their decision-making process, ethical considerations, and interpersonal skills.

  • Career Journey Mapping

Invite candidates to create a visual map of their career journey during the interview process. This can include key milestones, significant achievements, and challenging moments. This exercise helps candidates reflect on their professional path and offers recruiters insights into their career motivations, progress, and future aspirations.

  • Peer Interviewing

Involving future potential team members in the interview process can provide another layer of insight. Peer interviewers can ask questions that shed light on how the candidate might fit into the team and can probe more deeply into past experiences that are similar to those the team regularly encounters.

Ethical Considerations

While incorporating personal stories into the recruitment process offers significant benefits, recruiters and HR professionals must navigate this approach with a strong ethical framework. Below are some key ethical considerations to ensure that engaging with candidates' personal narratives remains respectful, fair, and legally compliant:

  • Relevance to the Role

Any personal information requested or discussed must be directly relevant to the candidate's ability to perform the job. Questions should be carefully designed to avoid prying into areas of personal life that do not have a direct impact on job performance. This helps prevent discrimination and maintains a professional focus.

  • Confidentiality and Privacy

Maintain strict confidentiality of any personal stories shared by candidates. This information should be protected with the same rigour as other sensitive personal data. Recruiters and HR personnel must ensure that only individuals directly involved in the hiring decision have access to this information, and it should be stored securely and disposed of appropriately when no longer needed.

  • Avoiding Bias

Recruiters must be vigilant against unconscious biases that might influence their judgement based on a candidate’s personal story. For instance, a candidate’s background or experiences should not lead to assumptions about their capabilities or work ethic. Structured approaches and training in unbiased recruitment practices can help mitigate these risks.

Learn More About Job Candidates by Hearing Their Stories

Understanding the person behind the CV is a powerful way to identify top talent. By engaging with candidates’ personal stories, recruiters and HR leaders can gain a fuller picture of potential employees, leading to more effective hiring decisions. This approach helps to enhance the recruitment process and also contributes to building a more cohesive and supportive workplace culture. As you move beyond the CV, try to embrace the rich, personal narratives that each candidate brings, transforming recruitment into a truly human-centric process.

If you’re looking to improve your recruitment efforts, then let our team at CNA International help. By partnering with us, you will enjoy a wealth of resources that will help improve how you handle recruitment. To learn more,  get in touch with CNA International today.


CNA International

E: | T: +44 (0) 1676 822 222 | W: 














Related Articles